Burnham Rejects Welsh Devolution Calls in Letter to First Minister, Saying He Is ‘Not Persuaded’
Prime Minister Andy Burnham has rejected calls to hand Wales control over policing, justice, the Crown Estate and rail infrastructure, telling Welsh First Minister Rhun ap Iorwerth in a letter on Friday that he is “not persuaded” by the case for devolving any of the four powers.
According to BBC Wales, which has seen the letter, Burnham refused each of Cardiff’s central demands in turn, arguing that the existing arrangements serve Wales better than transferring the powers to the Senedd. The rebuff, which landed on the same day Burnham was in Brussels signing a new agreement with the European Union, has infuriated the Welsh government and exposed a split inside the Labour movement over the future of the United Kingdom.
Ap Iorwerth accused the prime minister of “turning his back on devolution” and of failing to treat Wales as an “equal nation”. A spokesperson for the first minister said Burnham’s warm words about pushing power out of Whitehall were now “ringing hollow”, adding that when he spoke of driving power out of London, he meant only to the regions of England.
The row is the most serious constitutional clash between Downing Street and Cardiff since Burnham became prime minister in July, and it strikes at the heart of his political identity. Burnham built his reputation as Greater Manchester mayor on the argument that power should be pushed out of Westminster and closer to the people it affects. Now, in his first months in Downing Street, he has told one of the United Kingdom’s three devolved nations that its government should not be trusted with the powers Scotland already holds.
For Wales, the stakes are concrete rather than abstract. Policing and justice decide who is arrested, tried and imprisoned on Welsh streets. The Crown Estate controls the seabed off the Welsh coast, where the offshore wind farms of the coming decades will be built. Rail infrastructure decides whether Welsh lines are upgraded or left to decay. Each of the four powers has been demanded by Cardiff for years, and each has now been refused in a single letter.
The four refusals
Burnham’s letter dealt with the four powers one by one, and in each case his answer was the same: the current settlement should stay. The prime minister’s argument, as reported by the BBC, was not that Wales is incapable of running these services, but that keeping them inside United Kingdom-wide systems gives Wales access to resources, expertise and scale it would lose on its own.
Policing
On policing, Burnham argued for keeping the single England and Wales system, saying it was essential for forces on both sides of the border to work together seamlessly, to share specialist capabilities and to respond to threats. According to the BBC, he told ap Iorwerth that retaining the integrated framework would help ensure policing in Wales could respond effectively to threats and protect the public.
The argument is a familiar one in Whitehall. The four Welsh police forces — South Wales, Gwent, Dyfed-Powys and North Wales — are part of a single England and Wales policing structure, and ministers have long argued that breaking it apart would create friction at the border, duplicate expensive specialist units such as counter-terrorism and serious organised crime, and leave Welsh forces cut off from national databases and capabilities.
Cardiff’s counter-argument is that the division is already incoherent. Health, education, housing and social services are devolved to Wales, while the police, the courts, the prisons and probation remain reserved to Westminster. Welsh ministers argue that this split makes it harder to deal with the problems that drive crime — mental ill health, drug addiction, youth offending — because the services that could prevent offending answer to Cardiff while the services that punish it answer to London. Supporters of devolving policing also point out that the Senedd already funds community safety work and youth justice services, yet has no control over the police forces that work alongside them.
Justice
On justice, Burnham said he strongly believed the current settlement allowed Wales to benefit from the resources, expertise and resilience of a shared justice system. According to the BBC, he argued that partnership between London and Cardiff was essential to improving outcomes for victims, reducing reoffending and building safer communities.
Justice is the most symbolically charged of the four powers. Unlike Scotland, which has had its own legal system for centuries, Wales shares a single legal jurisdiction with England. There is no separate Welsh court system, no Welsh judiciary and no Welsh prison service. Cases in Wales are heard in magistrates’ courts and Crown Courts that form part of the England and Wales system, and Welsh prisoners are held in prisons run from London.
The demand to change that has grown steadily. The independent Commission on Justice in Wales, chaired by Lord Thomas of Cwmgiedd, the former Lord Chief Justice, concluded in 2019 that the justice system in Wales was failing and that policing and justice should be devolved. Its report argued that the current arrangement left Wales without a coherent justice policy of its own and without the ability to join up courts, prisons, probation and the devolved public services that surround them. The Welsh government has pressed the case ever since, and in 2020 the Senedd voted to support the devolution of justice and policing.
Burnham’s letter does not engage directly with that commission’s findings. Instead, it rests on the practical argument that a shared system gives Wales more — more expertise, more resilience, more resources — than a separate Welsh system could provide. It is the same logic that has been deployed by every prime minister since devolution began, and it is the logic that Cardiff has spent a decade trying to overturn.
The Crown Estate
On the Crown Estate, Burnham said its current model offered the best way of maximising the economic and social benefits for Wales, and that the UK government was not persuaded by the case for devolving its management in Wales, or even for preparing for a future transfer. According to the BBC, the prime minister refused not only the transfer itself but the idea of starting work towards one.
The Crown Estate is the portfolio of land and property owned by the monarch in right of the Crown. In Wales it includes the seabed off the Welsh coast, the foreshore, and rights over much of the country’s coastline. The land belongs to the reigning monarch, and the revenue from its property portfolio goes directly to the UK Treasury. The level of profit it generates is also used as a benchmark to calculate the funding given by the government to the Royal Family.
That arrangement is what makes the Crown Estate such a live political issue in Wales. The seabed off the Welsh coast is where the offshore wind farms of the Celtic Sea will be built, and the leases for those wind farms are among the most valuable assets in the entire Crown Estate portfolio. The previous Welsh Labour government and the current Plaid Cymru administration have both long argued that the revenue generated in Welsh waters should be spent in Wales, rather than flowing to the Treasury in London.
The comparison with Scotland is unavoidable, and it is the one that angers Cardiff most. In Scotland, the management of Crown Estate assets and the revenue they generate were transferred to the Scottish Parliament under the Scotland Act 2016, and Crown Estate Scotland was established on 1 April 2017. Its surplus revenue is paid into the Scottish Consolidated Fund, which helps finance the Scottish government. Wales, by contrast, has been told that even preparing for a similar transfer is not on the table.
The refusal is particularly striking because the Crown Estate is, in practical terms, the easiest of the four powers to devolve. It requires no new courts, no new police forces and no new legislation of the kind that justice devolution would demand. It is a transfer of management and revenue, and Scotland has already shown how it can be done. Burnham’s decision to refuse even exploratory work on it is what led ap Iorwerth’s spokesperson to say the prime minister did not view Wales as an “equal nation”.
Rail
On rail infrastructure, Burnham told the first minister that funding and delivery were best handled by the new Great British Railways, working in collaboration with Transport for Wales and the Welsh government. According to the BBC, he said full devolution would fragment the current system and affect the service provided to the public by the highly integrated cross-border network.
Rail is the most practically entangled of the four powers. The Welsh rail network is deeply woven into the English one: trains run from Cardiff to London, from Holyhead to Chester, from the Valleys into England and back, and the infrastructure itself — track, signalling, stations — is managed as part of a single network. Burnham’s argument is that splitting that network in two would create new borders where none currently exist, and that a single body, Great British Railways, can plan investment across the whole system more effectively than two separate ones.
Wales has long argued the opposite: that the single system has consistently short-changed it. Rail funding has been one of the most bitter grievances in Welsh politics for more than a decade, with Cardiff arguing that Wales receives a disproportionately small share of rail investment relative to the size of its network. The creation of Great British Railways, the new public body that will run the railways, was supposed to be an opportunity to reset that relationship. Burnham’s letter suggests that, from Downing Street’s point of view, the reset will happen inside the existing structure, not by changing who controls it.
Cardiff’s furious response
The Welsh government’s response was swift and unsparing. Ap Iorwerth accused Burnham of “turning his back on devolution”, a phrase calculated to wound a prime minister whose entire political brand is built on decentralisation. His spokesperson went further, saying the prime minister’s warm words on devolution were now “ringing hollow” and that his refusal even to explore devolving the Crown Estate, justice and policing, and rail infrastructure proved he did not view Wales as an “equal nation”.
The spokesperson also said Wales was being denied the chance to benefit from its own natural resources, to secure a fair share of rail investment, and to develop a justice system suited to its own needs. The language was deliberately chosen to frame the dispute not as a technical argument about administrative structures, but as a question of national status: whether Wales is a country within the United Kingdom, or merely a region of England with a parliament attached.
That framing matters because it is the ground on which Plaid Cymru has chosen to fight. Ap Iorwerth became first minister after the Senedd election in May, when Plaid Cymru defeated Welsh Labour in what the BBC described as a historic election defeat for the party that had governed Wales since devolution began. He leads a minority government, built on cooperation with other parties, with a programme for government that runs to 2030 and puts further devolution at its centre. For his administration, the devolution question is not one item on a long list. It is the test of whether his government can deliver anything at all.
A split inside Labour
Burnham’s position has also put him at odds with his own party in Wales. Ken Skates, the leader of Welsh Labour, reiterated at a party conference last weekend that policing and the Crown Estate should be devolved — the same position Burnham has now rejected in writing. According to the BBC, Burnham’s stance is directly at odds with the Welsh Labour leader’s.
The split is awkward for both men. Skates leads a party that has just lost power in Cardiff for the first time in the devolution era, and his argument is that Welsh Labour must show it still stands up for Wales if it is ever to win power back. Burnham leads a UK government that needs Welsh Labour MPs and members, and his argument is that the union is best served by keeping the big systems — policing, justice, rail — whole.
The tension was visible even before the letter. Burnham told party members last week that Welsh Labour may have lost sight of some of the principles of devolution before it was thrown out of power in its historic election defeat. The remark was read in Cardiff as a warning that the Welsh party had become too comfortable with the status quo. Now, days later, the prime minister has told the Welsh government that the status quo is exactly what he intends to preserve.
There is also a personal dimension. The BBC reported that Burnham had said he wanted to see “one Labour team” at the Welsh Labour Conference — a call for unity between the UK party and its Welsh branch. The letter to ap Iorwerth, a Plaid Cymru first minister, was in one sense an attempt to show that the prime minister deals with Cardiff on the merits, regardless of party. But by rejecting the very powers that Welsh Labour itself supports devolving, Burnham has made unity harder, not easier.
From Glasgow optimism to a Friday letter
What makes the letter sting in Cardiff is how sharply it reverses the mood of only a few weeks ago. Burnham and ap Iorwerth met in Glasgow last month, at a meeting of the National Economic Council, and the talks were described as positive. Asked afterwards about the prime minister’s position on devolving policing, ap Iorwerth said: “I think instinctively the prime minister wants to go there.” Burnham had also previously said he was open to the idea.
The Glasgow meeting was part of a wider effort by Burnham to reset relations with the devolved governments. He held substantive talks with both ap Iorwerth and Scotland’s first minister, John Swinney, focused on employment and reindustrialisation, and Downing Street characterised the discussions as constructive. The two first ministers used the occasion to assert that decisions about devolution belonged to their own parliaments, not to Westminster — a position that, at the time, looked like the opening of a negotiation rather than the prelude to a refusal.
The letter changes that reading entirely. Where ap Iorwerth had heard a prime minister who instinctively wanted to go further, the letter shows a prime minister who has decided not to go at all. The gap between the Glasgow mood and the Friday letter is the gap between a politician’s instincts and his government’s policy — and it is the gap that Cardiff is now exploiting, by quoting Burnham’s own earlier openness back at him.
It is not the first time Burnham’s approach to devolution has drawn criticism from Wales. Earlier this month, Lee Waters, the former Welsh transport minister who stepped down in 2024, said the prime minister’s plans to push powers down to regions and cities “just doesn’t work” in Wales. Waters argued that Burnham was transposing an English mayoral model onto a very different political geography, and that a country of three million people could not be treated as if it were a city region. The letter to ap Iorwerth will be read in Cardiff as confirmation of that criticism: devolution for English regions, but not for Wales.
Analysis: the devolutionist who said no
The deeper question raised by Burnham’s letter is not whether policing or the Crown Estate should be devolved. It is whether a prime minister who made his name as a devolutionist can refuse devolution and still keep his identity intact.
Burnham’s career has been defined by the argument that power should move out of Whitehall. As mayor of Greater Manchester from 2017 until he entered Downing Street in July, he argued relentlessly that decisions about transport, housing, health and skills should be taken in the places they affect, not in London. He won national attention for standing up to the Westminster government during the pandemic, when he refused to accept its terms for local restrictions without proper financial support. When he became prime minister on 20 July, succeeding Keir Starmer, the expectation was that the devolutionist would become the devolving prime minister.
His early months in office have indeed been marked by a push for English devolution. He has championed handing more powers to English regions and cities, and has spoken of driving power out of Whitehall as a central mission of his government. The letter to ap Iorwerth shows the limit of that mission. Power, it turns out, is to be driven out of Whitehall to the regions of England — not to the Senedd in Cardiff, and not, by extension, to the other devolved nations in the form of new powers.
There is a coherent argument for that position, and Burnham’s letter makes it. Policing, justice and rail are genuinely integrated systems, and breaking them apart would create real costs and real risks. A separate Welsh justice system would need its own courts, its own judiciary, its own prison estate and its own legal profession — an undertaking of enormous complexity and expense. A separate Welsh rail infrastructure would need to untangle a network that has been built as a single system for nearly two centuries. Even the Crown Estate, the simplest of the four, raises questions about how the monarchy’s revenues are accounted for and how the Royal Family is funded.
But the coherence of the argument does not remove the political problem. Burnham is asking Wales to accept that the very logic he applied to Greater Manchester — that local control produces better decisions — does not apply to a nation of three million people with its own parliament. He is asking Cardiff to accept that the benefits of scale outweigh the benefits of self-government, while telling English regions the opposite. And he is doing so at a moment when the party that has governed Wales for a generation has just been thrown out of power, and when the party that replaced it has made further devolution its defining promise.
The political risk for Burnham is that the letter becomes a symbol. In Welsh politics, symbols matter. The refusal to devolve the Crown Estate, in particular, is easy to explain and hard to defend: Scotland has it, Wales does not, and the money from Welsh waters goes to London. That is a sentence that can be repeated in every Senedd debate, every election leaflet and every television interview between now and the next Senedd election in 2030. Ap Iorwerth’s spokesperson has already framed it in exactly those terms, and the framing will not be easy to dislodge.
The risk for Cardiff is the opposite. Ap Iorwerth leads a minority government, and his leverage over Downing Street is limited. He cannot force the prime minister to devolve anything, and the Senedd cannot legislate on reserved matters. His options are to keep up the political pressure, to build a coalition of support across Welsh civic society, and to hope that the next UK government — or a future Burnham government under different political pressure — takes a different view. That is a slow strategy, and it depends on keeping the issue alive in public debate for years rather than weeks.
The Scotland comparison
At the heart of the dispute is a simple asymmetry. Scotland has a parliament with control over policing, justice, the Crown Estate and rail infrastructure. Wales has a parliament without them. The question is whether that asymmetry is a historical accident that should be corrected, or a reflection of a genuine constitutional difference between the two nations.
The history explains how the asymmetry arose, but it does not settle whether it should continue. Scotland kept its own legal system after the Act of Union in 1707, and its parliament, restored in 1999, inherited control over justice and policing as a matter of course. Wales, by contrast, was legally absorbed into England centuries earlier, and when its assembly was created in 1999 it was given only executive powers, with no primary law-making authority at all. It took a referendum in 2011 for the assembly to gain full law-making powers in the areas already devolved to it, and the Wales Act 2017 moved Wales to a reserved-powers model — under which anything not explicitly reserved to Westminster is devolved — without changing the reservation of policing and justice.
The Crown Estate shows how the asymmetry can be corrected when the political will exists. The Smith Commission, set up after the 2014 Scottish independence referendum, recommended that the management of Crown Estate assets in Scotland and the revenue they generate should be transferred to the Scottish Parliament. The Scotland Act 2016 gave effect to that recommendation, and the transfer took place on 1 April 2017. Crown Estate Scotland now manages the seabed, the foreshore, rural land and other assets, and its surplus revenue is paid into the Scottish Consolidated Fund.
Wales has no equivalent of the Smith Commission, no equivalent recommendation, and now, with Burnham’s letter, no equivalent transfer — not even the preparatory work for one. The Welsh government argues that the same logic that justified devolving the Crown Estate in Scotland applies in Wales: the assets are Welsh, the revenue is generated in Wales, and the money should be spent in Wales. Burnham’s answer is that the current model maximises the economic and social benefits for Wales, a claim that Cardiff disputes and that will now be tested in public debate.
What the Senedd can and cannot do
To understand why the letter matters so much in Cardiff, it helps to understand what the Senedd already controls — and what it does not. The Welsh Parliament, renamed Senedd Cymru in 2020, is responsible for most domestic policy in Wales: health, education, housing, local government, transport, economic development, social services, the environment, language and culture. It also has some tax-raising powers, including control over local taxes, taxes on property transactions, and the ability to vary income tax rates.
But it has no power over policing and justice, no power over the Crown Estate, no power over rail infrastructure, and no power over defence, foreign affairs or immigration. The Senedd has fewer powers than the Scottish Parliament and the Northern Ireland Assembly, and the gap is most visible in exactly the areas Burnham has now refused to devolve.
The Senedd has also grown. This year the number of its members increased from 60 to 96, reflecting the expansion of Welsh powers since devolution began in 1999. A larger parliament, with a broader democratic mandate, is now asking for the powers to match its size — and being told no.
The devolution settlement has always been described as a process rather than an event, a phrase coined by Ron Davies, the former Secretary of State for Wales, and repeated in the House of Commons Library’s authoritative briefing on the subject. The settlement has moved in stages: administrative devolution in the 1960s, executive devolution in 1999, enhanced powers in 2007, full law-making powers after the 2011 referendum, and the reserved-powers model in 2018. Each stage was contested at the time, and each was eventually accepted as the new normal. Burnham’s letter is, in effect, an attempt to declare that the process has stopped — at least for now, and at least for these four powers.
What to watch next
Several things will show whether the letter settles the argument or starts a longer one. The first is the Senedd’s response. Ap Iorwerth is expected to make a statement to the Senedd, and a debate on the letter is likely. The tone of that debate — whether it is a cross-party condemnation or a partisan row — will signal how much political capital Cardiff is prepared to spend on the issue.
The second is the Welsh budget. The Welsh government has announced its first draft budget under the Plaid Cymru administration, including extra funding for the NHS, and the budget debate will be the first test of whether the devolution row changes the politics of spending in Cardiff. If the row hardens attitudes, it could make the budget harder to pass in a minority government.
The third is Burnham’s own 10-year plan, which is expected to be unveiled in December. The plan is supposed to set out his government’s long-term direction, including on the constitution. If it contains a fuller account of his thinking on devolution — why English regions should gain powers while Wales should not — it will be read closely in Cardiff. If it says nothing, the silence will be read just as closely.
The fourth is the politics inside Labour. Skates has staked his party’s position on devolving policing and the Crown Estate. If the UK prime minister continues to refuse, Welsh Labour will have to decide whether to keep pressing the case — and risk open conflict with Downing Street — or to fall into line and risk looking irrelevant in Cardiff. That decision will shape Welsh Labour’s chances of returning to power in 2030.
The fifth, and most distant, is the next Senedd election. Ap Iorwerth’s programme for government runs to 2030, and his party’s pitch is that Wales should stand on an equal footing with Scotland at a bare minimum. If Burnham’s letter becomes the defining document of that pitch — the proof that Westminster will not give Wales what Scotland already has — it could shape the election as much as any domestic policy. And if Burnham changes his mind before then, the letter will be remembered as the moment the argument began, not the moment it ended.
For now, the letter stands as the clearest statement yet of where the devolutionist prime minister draws the line. Power will move out of Whitehall, he has told Wales — but only so far, and not to Cardiff.
Sources
- BBC News (Wales) — Andy Burnham rejects calls for devolution of powers to Wales in letter to Rhun ap Iorwerth
- House of Commons Library — Devolution in Wales: “A process, not an event”
- Scottish Government — The Scottish Crown Estate
- UK Parliament — Written question: policing and criminal justice reserved in Wales under the Wales Act 2017
- Encyclopaedia Britannica — Wales: Government and society