Tuesday, 17 November 2026
NEXA NEWSHD
UK

Milburn Review Calls for ‘Complete System Reset’ to Rescue a Million Young Britons From Joblessness

Britain should tear up the way it supports its young people and start again, according to a major government-commissioned review published in full on Tuesday, which warns that almost a million 16 to 24-year-olds are now outside education, employment or training — and that without radical change the number will keep climbing for years.

The review, led by Alan Milburn, a former Labour health secretary, calls for what it describes as a “complete system reset” in how public services support young people, backed by a legal guarantee of education, training or work for every young person, a new Youth Opportunity Service in every part of England, and a benefits system for under-25s rebuilt around opportunity rather than payments.

“Britain has had a youth NEET problem for 25 years and never a plan to end it,” Milburn said, according to the BBC. “We are at a fork in the road and half measures will not do. A complete system reset is needed.”

The report, titled From a Welfare State to a Working State: A new settlement for the next generation, sets a ten-year ambition to cut the share of young people not in education, employment or training — known as NEETs — from 13 per cent to around 5 per cent by 2036. That, the review says, would make Britain one of the best performers in Europe on youth participation, and would help around 440,000 young people into work.

The scale of the problem the review describes is stark. Nearly one million young people, one in eight of all 16 to 24-year-olds, are currently NEET, according to the BBC and the Press Association. Six in ten of them have never had a job. The NEET rate, at 13 per cent, is the highest since 2014, and the review warns that on current policy it could reach 16.3 per cent — around 1.27 million young people — by 2031. Youth disengagement already costs the country about £125 billion a year, the review estimates.

Parts of the plan were trailed last week, when the outlines of the legal guarantee and the welfare overhaul first emerged. The full report, published on Tuesday, puts the detail behind those headlines for the first time, along with the first full set of reactions from ministers, opposition parties, business groups and charities — and the first clear picture of who would gain, and who would lose, under the most far-reaching shake-up of youth policy in a generation.

At a press conference on Tuesday, Milburn was expected to frame the choice in moral as well as economic terms. “A lost generation is not a fact of life. It is a choice. And I believe it is the wrong one,” he was expected to say, according to the Press Association. “Not just because it is a fiscal crisis or an economic crisis. But because it is a moral one. We are failing as a nation to gift the next generation the opportunities they need to succeed. It is time for a new settlement that makes work not welfare the future for the next generation.”

“A lost generation is not inevitable. A work generation is possible,” he said, in remarks carried by the BBC and the Press Association. “This is not simply a cause for young people. It is a cause for the country. We have to make the next generation a national priority. Youth participation has to run through public policy like a stick of rock.”

A new service at the heart of the plan

At the centre of the review sits a new local Youth Opportunity Service, which Milburn describes as the “engine room of a Working State”. The service would bring together employment, careers, health and practical support around a young person in one place, with a personalised participation plan and a named adviser.

Two new guarantees in law would underpin it. An Opportunity Guarantee would give every young person a route into education, training or work. A Support Guarantee would give them the health, employment and practical help needed to take it up. Strategic authorities and mayors would be accountable for delivery through multi-year Participation Agreements, with a Youth Opportunity Service in every area by 2029, according to FE News, which published a detailed account of the report.

Each young person would be paired with a named adviser and offered a personal plan leading to an apprenticeship, a college place, supported employment or a job within four months, according to the BBC. The service would answer to regional mayors and local leaders, rather than being run from Whitehall.

The report proposes that the guarantee should apply to every young person who is NEET, whether or not they claim benefits. That matters, because the government’s existing Jobs Guarantee — under which the state underwrites a paid six-month job — is tied to the benefits system. The Department for Work and Pensions announced over the weekend that the existing scheme would be extended to people who have been on Universal Credit for 12 months, down from 18 months. But that offer is not a legal duty, and it reaches only those inside the welfare system. Milburn’s version would be a statutory entitlement for all 18 to 24-year-olds.

The review also proposes multi-billion-pound public investment to underpin the Opportunity Guarantee, according to the Press Association, and says plainly that crude benefit cuts will not work and that reform will need upfront investment. Savings, it argues, start early and build over the decade.

The welfare overhaul: a Youth Allowance for under-25s

The most contested part of the report is its overhaul of benefits for under-25s. Young adults would no longer be eligible for the health top-up of Universal Credit, which provides extra money for people with a long-term health condition or disability, or for Personal Independence Payment, known as PIP. In their place would come a Youth Allowance set at the current base rate of Universal Credit, and a new Additional Cost Allowance for significant disability-related costs. Those who can never work would be supported through a new Severe and Complex Needs Insurance, according to the BBC.

People with the most profound conditions that prevent work would retain more generous financial help, according to the Guardian, which reported the proposals in detail. But the direction of travel is unmistakable: money that now arrives as a benefit payment would increasingly arrive as support, training and a route into a job.

The review justifies the shift with a single striking comparison. In 2024 to 2025, for every £25 spent on youth benefits, only £1 went on helping young people into work or education. The report aims to rebalance that to £2 spent on benefits for every £1 spent on work support by 2036 — a ratio it describes as among the best in Europe.

Milburn has already acknowledged that his proposals would not be “pain-free”, giving a candid warning that they could lead to some people getting less financial support, according to the Press Association. The review says the changes must be backed by major new investment in support, training and jobs before any benefit changes take effect.

For the young people the system is meant to serve, the trade-off is personal as well as financial. The BBC reported the case of Kat, 21, from Devon, who receives Universal Credit with the health top-up and could see her payments fall sharply under the new system. She lives with fluctuating physical and mental health problems, including occasional seizures linked to a functional neurological disorder, and has recently needed crutches. She says she really wants to work, but has not found a job where she can be employed in a safe way.

Her case captures the argument the review will have to win: that a system built around a named adviser, a personal plan and a guaranteed route into work can do more for a young person in her position than a monthly payment alone. Critics will ask what happens to those for whom the route into work does not arrive on schedule, and whether the safety net underneath them is strong enough.

From the first years of life to the first job

Unusually for a review about youth unemployment, Milburn’s report reaches back to the start of life. It proposes that 90 per cent of children should arrive at school ready to learn, with basic life skills, by the age of five. The current figure in England is 68 per cent, against a government target of 75 per cent by 2028, according to the BBC. Schools would put more emphasis on work skills, and the curriculum would be rebalanced towards the skills young people need for work.

Colleges and apprenticeships would be reshaped too. The report proposes doubling the number of young people achieving an apprenticeship over the decade, so that apprenticeships rival university as a mainstream route for school leavers, according to FE News. That would mean a very large expansion of a system that has struggled for years to grow beyond its current size, and it would depend on employers offering the places.

On health, the review proposes instant access to needs-based mental health support without waiting for a diagnosis, and fast-track help for young people who are NEET. The point, the report argues, is that a young person who cannot get help for anxiety or depression will not be in a position to take up a job or a college place, however good the offer is. Mental ill-health is one of the main drivers of the rise in youth inactivity, and the review treats it as a barrier to work rather than a separate issue.

For employers, the review proposes a new bargain: the state makes it cheaper, simpler and less risky to hire a young person, and employers create more first chances. The report proposes gradually lowering the National Insurance employers pay for young adult workers, starting in retail and hospitality, and doubling the point at which employers start paying National Insurance for this age group, from £5,000 to £10,000 a year, according to Energy Radio, which reported the detail.

Two existing schemes would stay. The Youth Jobs Grant pays employers £3,000 for hiring a young person who has been out of work for six months. The Jobs Guarantee underwrites a paid six-month job, with young adults soon qualifying after 12 months on Universal Credit rather than 18, according to the BBC.

And the review proposes a statutory Youth Opportunity Test, under which major tax, spending and regulatory decisions would be assessed on their effect on the next generation before they are made. The idea is that youth participation should be weighed in the same way as the effect of a policy on the public finances — built into the decision, rather than considered afterwards.

A problem 25 years in the making

The review sets its case against a long history of failure. Britain’s NEET rate has never fallen below 9.7 per cent since records began in 2001, according to the Press Association. Milburn says the country has had a youth NEET problem for 25 years and never a plan to end it.

The comparison with other countries is unflattering. Across Europe, only Romania had a higher NEET rate than the UK in 2025, according to FE News. The Netherlands, by contrast, has a NEET rate of 4.8 per cent. The review argues that the crisis is a choice, and that other countries have made a different one.

The causes the review identifies are familiar but compounding: employers freezing hiring plans, the after-effects of the pandemic and austerity, rising mental ill-health, and artificial intelligence reshaping the jobs market, according to the BBC. Young people are entering a labour market in which entry-level jobs are scarcer, competition for them is fiercer, and the path from education into work is less clearly marked than it was a generation ago.

The regional picture is sharply uneven. The latest government figures estimate that 20.3 per cent of young people in the North East are NEET, the highest rate in the country. The next highest is Yorkshire and the Humber on 15.1 per cent, with the North West on 14 per cent, for the year to June 2026, according to the Press Association. In the North East, nearly one in four young people are outside education, employment or training.

Kim McGuinness, the North East Mayor, said the figures were stark. “The North East has by some margin the highest rates of so-called NEETs in the country,” she said. “Nearly one in four of our young people are being denied the opportunities they deserve. These are young people wanting work and looking for work who feel let down.” She added that the region was already developing an adult skills programme, launching an apprenticeship “talent pool” matching service, investing in a £30 million child poverty action plan and funding additional education and training places across schools and colleges.

The review team visited four focus areas during its research, including Benwell in Newcastle’s West End, according to the Press Association. The choice of places matters to the argument: the crisis is not evenly spread, and a plan designed in Whitehall and applied uniformly would miss the places where it is worst.

The politics: praise, caution and alarm

The report has drawn a mixed response, and the dividing lines are already clear. The Conservatives said they would back the parts Milburn gets right, but the shadow work and pensions secretary, Helen Whately, called the plan in places too cautious and too reliant on the expensive hand of the state, and said it would not cut the welfare bill, according to the BBC.

Reform UK said a ten-year wait would consign another generation to the scrap heap, according to the BBC. The Greens called the proposals extremely concerning and warned against threatening vulnerable people with the loss of benefits they need.

Labour backbenchers from the left of the party have also raised concerns, writing that young people need opportunity rather than punishment, and warning that benefit cuts risk pushing further away those already struggling, according to the BBC. The work and pensions secretary, Pat McFadden, sought to reassure them, describing the plan as a new settlement that brings together the help young people need in one place.

Andy Burnham, the prime minister, has been urged by Milburn to spend billions on the new deal, according to the Guardian, and has promised to intervene from early childhood and said benefit changes would come only with a root-and-branch rethink of youth support. The Guardian reported that Milburn’s review urges Burnham and the government to invest billions in a new system of support for young people, alongside a stricter benefits regime for under-25s.

Milburn himself has urged the prime minister not to shy away from welfare reform, while warning that crude benefit cuts alone would not work and that the changes need upfront investment, according to the BBC. The Institute for Fiscal Studies added that the reforms stand a better chance if support for young people is balanced with incentives for businesses to hire them.

Business groups were broadly supportive but pointed to the practical obstacles. Shevaun Haviland, director general of the British Chambers of Commerce, said the challenge was massive and the review did not shirk from it. “Having almost a million young adults outside education, employment or training is a huge waste of talent that we simply cannot afford,” she said. “Businesses want to give young people opportunities. But too often they are arriving in the jobs market with little workplace experience, while the costs and risks of taking them on continue to rise.”

Helen Dickinson, chief executive of the British Retail Consortium, said Milburn rightly recognised the critical role retail can play and the need to reduce the cost of entry-level jobs. Retailers are playing their part through a new national retail work experience programme, Opening Shift, helping NEETs break the “no experience, no job” cycle, she said. “But experience is not enough if there is no job at the end of it. Government must heed Milburn’s call and make it easier for businesses to hire, train, and invest in the next generation.”

Tina McKenzie, national chair of the Federation of Small Businesses, said helping one million small employers in local communities to afford to create roles was the only way to make significant inroads. “Increasing young entrepreneurship through self-employment is going to be fundamental too,” she said. “Many young people want to set up on their own, and that route is vital for social mobility.”

Allen Simpson, chief executive of UK Hospitality, said hospitality, as the largest employer of young people in the economy, stood ready to provide the job opportunities young people need to be part of the work generation. Steve Rotheram, Mayor of the Liverpool City Region, welcomed the recognition that the answers would not all come from Whitehall, and said giving mayors the powers and resources to bring together skills, employment and health support was exactly the joined-up thinking needed.

Charities focused on the safety net. Jon Sparkes, chief executive of Mencap, said the Opportunity and Support Guarantees would make a real difference, but added that a strong, secure safety net was needed so that young people with a learning disability were not disadvantaged. Lynn Perry, chief executive of Barnardo’s, said a million young people were being denied the opportunity to fulfil their potential, and that some were spending months or years on a waiting list for mental health services while others could not afford the basics like bus fare or interview clothes.

Brian Dow, chief executive of Mental Health UK, welcomed the emphasis on early, personalised and joined-up support, but said it would be vital that support remained at the heart of the system, and that young people who would be too unwell to work even with the best support in the world needed to be protected. Dame Rachel de Souza, the Children’s Commissioner for England, said young people were ambitious and wanted to work, but hit a brick wall of endless applications and automated rejections, and wanted vocational opportunities, work experience and support to thrive.

Andy Haldane, chief executive of the Royal Society of Arts, called the report a blueprint. “There is no more pressing challenge — economically, societally, morally — than reducing the young person’s NEET problem in the UK,” he said. “Alan Milburn’s report provides the blueprint for doing so. It is now for Government to summon the resources and political will to deliver on that blueprint.”

Analysis: Why It Matters

A report that refuses to be modest

The most striking thing about Milburn’s review is its refusal to be modest. Most government-commissioned reviews arrive with a handful of recommendations, a pilot scheme and a request for more research. This one proposes to rewrite the benefits system for everyone under 25, to create a new statutory service in every part of England, to impose a legal duty on the state to find every young person a route into work, and to judge every major government decision by its effect on the next generation. It is, deliberately, a plan for a decade rather than a parliament.

That ambition is both its strength and its vulnerability. A ten-year plan survives only if the government that commissions it, and the governments that follow it, keep funding it. The review’s own history makes the point: Britain has had a youth NEET problem for 25 years, through governments of every colour, and none of them has solved it. A plan that takes ten years to deliver will outlive at least two general elections. Its fate will be decided not by the applause on publication day, but by whether the next spending review protects it, and whether the one after that does too.

The welfare trade is the argument that matters

Strip away the architecture of services and guarantees, and the review turns on a single exchange: young people give up some of the cash support they receive today, and in return they get a named adviser, a personal plan, a guaranteed route into work, and a system that spends far more on helping them than it does now. Milburn’s case is that the current deal is a bad one — £25 on benefits for every £1 on help — and that a young person is better served by a job than by a payment.

The case is strong in the aggregate and fragile in the particular. In the aggregate, a million young people outside work and learning is a waste of talent and a bill of £125 billion a year, and no country that spends twenty-five times more on maintaining the problem than on solving it can call its system rational. In the particular, there is Kat, 21, from Devon, who wants to work, cannot find a job she can do safely, and could see her payments fall. The review’s answer is that she would get a named adviser, fast-track mental health support and a personal plan, and that the most severely affected would keep more generous help. Whether that answer is good enough will be tested not in the report’s modelling, but in the lives of the first young people who move from the old system to the new one — and in what happens to them if the job does not arrive within four months.

The political danger for the government is on both flanks at once. From the right, the charge is that the plan spends billions and does not cut the welfare bill. From the left, the charge is that it punishes the vulnerable. Milburn’s defence — that crude benefit cuts will not work, and that reform needs upfront investment — is designed to hold the middle ground. But the middle ground is narrow, and it narrows further the first time a young person loses money and the story reaches the newspapers.

The guarantee is only as good as the jobs behind it

A legal guarantee of education, training or work is a powerful promise. It is also, on its own, only a promise. The review proposes to double apprenticeships, to cut the cost of hiring young people, and to underwrite six-month jobs through the Jobs Guarantee. But apprenticeships require employers to offer them, and the history of apprenticeship policy in England is a history of targets missed and places that never materialised.

The employer side of the bargain is therefore the part to watch most closely. The phased cut to National Insurance for 21 to 24-year-olds, starting in retail and hospitality, and the doubling of the threshold to £10,000, are designed to make a first hire cheaper. The Youth Jobs Grant of £3,000 is designed to make it less risky. Whether those sums are large enough to change a hiring decision in a small business — the kind of business the Federation of Small Businesses says must create most of the roles — is an open question. A £3,000 grant is a meaningful sum for a small employer, but it is not a reason to create a job that does not exist.

There is also a timing problem. The Youth Opportunity Service is to be in every area by 2029. The apprenticeship doubling is a ten-year ambition. The NEET rate target is 2036. A young person who is 19 today will be 29 by the time the plan is fully delivered. The review’s answer is that the guarantees and the investment start now, and that the numbers move early. But the gap between a promise made today and a service delivered in 2029 is where political patience runs out, and where a generation that has already waited too long is asked to wait a little longer.

Starting at five is the most radical idea in the report

The least noticed proposal in the review may be the most radical. Milburn wants 90 per cent of children to arrive at school ready to learn, with basic life skills, by the age of five. The current figure in England is 68 per cent. That is a target that reaches into nurseries, parenting, health visiting and the earliest years of a child’s life — long before any young person becomes a NEET statistic.

It is also the proposal that most clearly shows the review’s diagnosis: that youth unemployment is not a problem that begins at 16. It begins with a child who arrives at school behind, falls further behind through school, leaves without the skills employers want, and then finds that the system built to catch them is a benefits office rather than a person. By the time a young person is counted as NEET, the review argues, a dozen earlier systems have already failed them. Fixing the end of the pipeline without fixing the start is, on this reading, a waste of effort.

The difficulty is that school readiness is a target the government has already set and already missed. The current ambition is 75 per cent by 2028, against 68 per cent now. Milburn wants 90 per cent, without a date attached in the published accounts of the report. A target that ambitious, set against a record of missed targets, will need more than repetition. It will need the same thing the rest of the report needs: money, delivered early, and sustained long enough to show up in the statistics.

What happens next will be decided by money, not by applause

The report has been welcomed by almost everyone who has read it, which is precisely the moment to be careful. Reviews are cheap to praise and expensive to deliver. The test of this one will not be the press conference, or the supportive quotes from mayors and business groups, but the spending decisions that follow: whether the Treasury funds the Youth Opportunity Service in every area, whether the multi-billion-pound investment behind the Opportunity Guarantee survives the next spending review, and whether the benefit changes arrive after the support is in place, as Milburn insists they must, or before it, as the Treasury may prefer.

Milburn has warned that the changes need upfront investment and that savings start early and build over the decade. That is the language of a review that knows its own vulnerability: a government under fiscal pressure will be tempted to take the savings — the reshaped benefits, the lower payments for some — and to delay the spending. If that happens, the review’s central bargain collapses, and the young people it is meant to help will have given up cash support for a service that has not yet arrived.

The prime minister’s response will be the first indication of which way that goes. Burnham has promised to intervene from early childhood and said benefit changes would come only with a root-and-branch rethink of youth support. The review gives him the blueprint for that rethink. Whether he gives it the money is a separate decision, and it is the one that will decide whether a million young people get a work generation, or another lost one.

What to Watch Next

  1. The government’s formal response to the review, and whether ministers accept the Opportunity Guarantee and the Youth Opportunity Service in full, in part, or in principle only.
  2. The next spending review, where the multi-billion-pound investment behind the guarantees will either be funded or quietly deferred.
  3. The timing of the benefit changes: whether the Youth Allowance and the new Additional Cost Allowance arrive after the support is in place, as Milburn insists, or before it.
  4. The first Youth Opportunity Services, and whether the named adviser and four-month personal plan work in practice in the areas where NEET rates are highest, above all the North East.
  5. The apprenticeship numbers: whether employers, helped by the National Insurance cut and the £3,000 Jobs Grant, actually double the number of young people completing apprenticeships.
  6. The school-readiness figures: whether the share of children arriving at school ready to learn moves from 68 per cent towards the 90 per cent ambition.
  7. The NEET rate itself, published quarterly, and whether the 13 per cent figure begins to fall — or keeps climbing towards the 1.27 million the review warns of by 2031.

Sources

About the Author — Abdul Mannan

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *