Russia Stalls UN ‘Killer Robot’ Talks in Geneva as US Opposes Binding Rules on Autonomous Weapons
Delegates from 128 countries gathered in Geneva on Monday for what supporters of new rules on autonomous weapons call the last realistic chance to bring them under international law — and within minutes, the meeting had stalled. Russia objected to letting observers, including the European Union and civil society groups, speak in the opening session of the Seventh Review Conference of the Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons, blocking adoption of the agenda and forcing the chair to suspend the conference on its first day, according to Reuters and Geneva Solutions.
The conference, meeting at the Palais des Nations from 16 to 20 November, must decide whether to open formal negotiations on a legally binding instrument governing lethal autonomous weapons systems — machines that can select and attack targets without a human deciding to fire. It is a question diplomats have debated for 13 years. The review conference that must answer it meets only once every five years, and the expert group that spent three years drafting the possible elements of an instrument saw its mandate expire at the end of 2026.
Most of the 128 states party to the convention support opening negotiations. Seven of them — Austria, Belgium, Brazil, Ireland, Mexico, New Zealand and Panama — formally proposed in October that talks on a binding agreement begin. At least 50 countries, including Ireland, Italy, Brazil, Mexico, France and Germany, are calling for a strict timetable to agree on binding rules, according to NPR.
But three of the states that matter most to the outcome are lined up against a binding treaty. The United States, Russia and Israel have indicated they will oppose legally binding rules, according to Reuters and NPR, and Washington has instead proposed five more years of expert work towards a non-binding set of guidelines. Because the convention decides by consensus, any one government can block a decision — and on Monday, Russia showed how that veto works in practice before the substance of the debate had even begun.
The chair, Swiss disarmament ambassador Julien Thöni, said no agreement had been found and suspended the conference, according to Geneva Solutions. Informal consultations on the weapons were scheduled to begin on Tuesday, with observers allowed to take part. The conference is due to decide by Friday whether to open negotiations. Russia is expected to renew its procedural objections.
A suspension before the agenda was set
The opening session ran aground within minutes of starting, according to Geneva Solutions. Russia raised its nameplate to speak and objected to the longstanding practice of allowing observers to address the meeting, demanding that they — in this case the European Union and civil society groups — be allowed to comment only at the end of the session, after states had finished every substantive item. Moscow had used the same tactic at two other convention meetings the previous week, according to Reuters.
Ireland, which currently holds the presidency of the Council of the European Union, rejected the move, saying meaningful participation meant “meaningful engagement and exchange of views”, according to Reuters. The United Kingdom, Canada and Norway were among the states that opposed the block, according to the reporting, and the American delegation spoke against Russia on that point. Belarus backed Russia. No other delegation supported the Russian move, according to the coverage.
By the end of the day, Thöni returned to the room and announced that no agreement had been found, according to Geneva Solutions. With the conference still in a state of suspension, he said informal consultations on lethal autonomous weapons would begin on Tuesday, and that observers would be allowed to participate in them.
Anna Hehir, head of military AI governance at the Future of Life Institute, who was in the Assembly Hall as countries peeled off for informal talks, called the episode “another case of consensus paralysis”, according to Geneva Solutions. She said she would be surprised if Russia did not try to push back against the decision to let observers take part in the informal consultations on Tuesday, and warned that any process in which civil society cannot participate or help influence decision-making would be “a serious erosion of the credibility of the process”.
Beatrice Fihn, founder and director of Lex International and a former executive director of the International Campaign to Abolish Nuclear Weapons, said in a statement carried by Geneva Solutions: “Some states are weaponising consensus, on both procedural and substantive issues, to ensure that there will be no outcome this week.” She added, in comments to Geneva Solutions on the sidelines of the meeting: “It’s really up to the rest of the world to decide how to get around these delay tactics.”
Russia’s foreign ministry had already made its substantive position clear before the conference opened. Its spokeswoman, Maria Zakharova, called it “premature” to say the time had come for restrictions or bans on such systems, according to the Associated Press.
Guterres: a moral red line
United Nations Secretary-General António Guterres opened the meeting with a video message urging states to “move towards negotiating a legally binding instrument” with “clear prohibitions and restrictions”, according to Reuters and NPR. “I urge you to seize this moment. Take action to prevent the use and spread of these merciless weapons,” he said, according to the reporting of his message.
Guterres warned that allowing fully autonomous weapons to kill would be “crossing a moral red line”, according to NPR. It is a phrase he has used before, and a position he has held since soon after taking office. In November 2018, speaking at the Web Summit in Lisbon, he called for a ban for the first time, saying machines that have the power and discretion to take human lives are “politically unacceptable, are morally repugnant and should be banned by international law”, according to the Stop Killer Robots campaign’s account of his record.
In 2021, at the General Debate of the 76th session of the General Assembly, he warned: “Today, autonomous weapons can choose targets and kill people without human interference. They should be banned.” In July 2023, in his New Agenda for Peace policy brief, he recommended that states conclude, by 2026, a legally binding instrument to prohibit autonomous weapons that function without human control or oversight and cannot comply with international humanitarian law, and to regulate all other types.
In August 2026, Guterres and the president of the International Committee of the Red Cross, Mirjana Spoljaric, renewed their call in a joint statement, arguing that “negotiations must begin now to urgently adopt a legally binding instrument to regulate autonomous weapon systems with clear prohibitions and restrictions”. They warned that the world was now “dangerously close to crossing a moral red line: the autonomous targeting of humans by machines.” In September, in his last opening address to the General Assembly as Secretary-General, Guterres was unequivocal: “Let us resolve that life-and-death decisions must never be surrendered to machines. Killer robots must have no place in our future.”
Spoljaric put the stakes plainly in the run-up to the conference, according to the reporting: “Future generations will judge whether leaders acted to prevent a world where machines autonomously kill humans.”
Pope Leo XIV has also urged governments at the Geneva meeting to adopt binding rules, according to the reporting. The UN High Commissioner for Human Rights, Volker Türk, made the narrower argument on the eve of the conference: “A machine must never have the power to decide whether a human being survives or dies.”
What the Red Cross actually wants
It is worth being precise about what the International Committee of the Red Cross is asking for, because it is not a total ban. The organisation wants prohibitions on two categories of system — autonomous weapons that target people, and weapons that humans cannot understand, predict, explain or control — and regulation of all other types.
The Red Cross is especially worried that existing rules of war, the Geneva Conventions, cannot be fully respected by autonomous weapons. War is often chaotic and confusing, and the situation can change rapidly. Under the Conventions, soldiers who are wounded or in the process of surrendering can no longer be targeted.
Georgia Hinds, a legal adviser with the Red Cross, told NPR: “The risk is that, based on the technology we are seeing, they are not able to understand in the same way that a human is the contextual signals. And so the risks are incredibly high that there will be a misidentification of a target.” She worries that autonomous weapons will not be able to distinguish between a soldier who is still fighting, one who is wounded and one who wants to surrender.
Human rights groups warn separately that the technology behind AI-assisted weapons is becoming increasingly cheap and easy to use. The more it is adopted by the military, the greater the danger of proliferation and its use by terrorist groups or by law enforcement agencies in repressive regimes. In theory, according to NPR, a swarm of autonomous drones could be programmed to kill everyone wearing a red sweater, everyone carrying a poster or even everyone speaking a certain language.
Three positions, one veto
The conference now has three competing proposals for what happens next, and the rules of the forum mean any one of them can be blocked by a single state.
The first is the binding route. Thöni, the conference chair, has floated a two-year mandate to negotiate a binding protocol. The chair of the committee handling the issue, Peru’s Ambassador Elmer Schialer Salcedo, circulated a competing draft on 23 October. Seven states — Austria, Belgium, Brazil, Ireland, Mexico, New Zealand and Panama — formally proposed in October that negotiations on a legally binding agreement begin. The campaign group Stop Killer Robots counts 130 countries in favour of new international rules.
The second is the middle ground. Britain, Germany and France want talks that leave open whether the result would be binding. Their position is that a negotiating mandate should be agreed without deciding the legal form of the outcome at the start.
The third is the American position. In a working paper dated 4 November, Washington proposed five more years of expert work — ten days of meetings a year — towards a non-binding instrument agreed by consensus, with a first version in 2029 and a report to the 2031 review conference. The paper argues that existing humanitarian law already governs the weapons and that a new treaty is unnecessary, that it has not been established that autonomous weapons are inherently indiscriminate, and that appropriate use of autonomy can “reduce the risks to civilians” compared with weapons that lack it.
The United States is traditionally a late adopter of international treaties. It did not ratify the Ottawa Convention on landmines, for example, although it did, over time, stop deploying them and reduce its stockpiles, according to NPR. Under President Trump, doubts about international law have grown. Washington has imposed sweeping sanctions on the International Criminal Court, and just this weekend, Secretary of State Marco Rubio, in a keynote speech to the Federalist Society, warned against “quoting laws to men with swords”, according to NPR.
The American rules on autonomous weapons are set out in Department of Defense Directive 3000.09, last reissued in January 2023.
The General Assembly’s disarmament committee voted on 29 October to steer the convention towards negotiations, by 163 votes to five, with nine abstentions. The five against were the United States, Russia, Belarus, Israel and North Korea. China was among the abstentions. It was the fourth year running that the committee has passed a text on the subject. The resolution is a political signal, not a treaty, and it does not bind this conference — but it shows how isolated the opponents of binding rules are in a majority vote, and how powerful the consensus rule of the convention is in protecting them.
The weapons are already here
The debate in Geneva is not about a distant future. AI-assisted weapons are already in use in Ukraine, Gaza and Sudan, though those remain under human control, according to Reuters. In Ukraine and Gaza, AI-assisted weapons have already been used to take out targets, according to NPR, and Ukrainian civilians have reported being “hunted” by drones as they shop or go to school — though those weapons are still controlled remotely by humans.
Whether a fully autonomous weapon has already killed without human approval is disputed, and the article does not present it as established fact. The New York Times reported in August 2026 that a Russian drone operating entirely through artificial intelligence killed three Ukrainian civilians. France 24 has reported that both Russian and Ukrainian forces have fielded drones capable of identifying and striking pre-programmed targets even after losing contact with their operators. But none of the reporting on the Geneva talks confirms that a fully autonomous lethal weapon is in use anywhere, and the question of whether one has killed without human approval remains contested.
That uncertainty is itself part of the argument in Geneva. The supporters of binding rules say the world is months away from weapons that can choose targets and make the decision to kill autonomously, according to NPR, and that the time to set rules is before such weapons are in widespread use. The opponents say the technology is not yet at the point where a treaty is needed, and that the law that already exists is enough.
The Group of Governmental Experts on Lethal Autonomous Weapons Systems, a UN body established in 2016, spent three years working on the elements of a possible instrument. It adopted a report in September 2026 containing elements that could form the basis of an instrument, without deciding in advance what legal form the instrument should take. Its mandate expires at the end of 2026. The review conference now meeting in Geneva is expected to consider those elements and determine the next mandate. The conference’s programme places the autonomous-weapons question in Main Committee II during 17 to 19 November, with adoption of the final document scheduled for 20 November.
The history of the convention
The Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons is not a new idea. It was adopted in 1980 to prohibit or restrict weapons considered excessively injurious or to have indiscriminate effects, and it has 128 High Contracting Parties. Its review conferences meet once every five years.
The convention’s record shows both what consensus can achieve and what it cannot. In 1995, countries agreed by consensus to a ban on blinding lasers. But other agreements have proved elusive, and the convention’s requirement that decisions be taken by consensus has repeatedly allowed a single state to block progress. With landmines, countries frustrated by the delay finally took negotiations outside the UN process to create the Ottawa Convention in 1997. The same route produced the 2008 ban on cluster munitions — which the major military powers never joined.
That history is why the frustrated states in Geneva are weighing whether to move the fight to the General Assembly, where decisions pass by majority, or to a stand-alone treaty negotiated outside the UN, according to Reuters. Either route would produce rules that the major military powers could simply refuse to join — which is why most of the 128 states in the room still prefer to keep negotiating inside the convention, even after Monday’s suspension.
This week, there may be a compromise: a longer or even open-ended negotiating period to come up with rules that individual states can adopt as binding or non-binding, according to NPR. For diplomats supporting such a solution, it is a way to ensure at least some progress. For campaigners, it is less than ideal, with one likening it to kicking a very dangerous can down the road.
Analysis: Why It Matters
Monday was about who may speak, not about the weapons — and that is the point
Nothing was decided about autonomous weapons on Monday, because nothing could be decided: the conference never adopted its agenda. Russia’s objection was procedural — whether observers, including the European Union and civil society groups, could speak — and it was enough to suspend the meeting. That is not a quirk of this conference. It is the design of the Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons, which decides by consensus and therefore hands every state a veto. The supporters of binding rules have spent 13 years learning that lesson, and the opponents have spent 13 years using it. Monday’s suspension was a reminder, delivered in the first minutes of the most important week in the debate’s history, that the argument in Geneva is not only about what the rules should say. It is about whether the forum that is supposed to write them is capable of writing anything at all.
The numbers are lopsided, and that changes nothing
The arithmetic of this debate is extraordinary. The General Assembly’s disarmament committee voted 163 to five in favour of steering the convention towards negotiations. At least 50 states want a strict timetable for binding rules. Stop Killer Robots counts 130 countries in favour of new international rules. And yet the five states that voted against — the United States, Russia, Belarus, Israel and North Korea — include the three countries that develop and deploy the most advanced autonomous weapons, and the convention’s consensus rule gives each of them a veto. This is the central paradox of the Geneva process: the more overwhelming the majority, the more the minority’s veto matters. It is also why the frustrated states keep threatening to take the negotiation elsewhere. A treaty written outside the UN, or a resolution passed by majority in the General Assembly, would not bind the United States, Russia or Israel. But it would bind almost everyone else, and it would make the three holdouts the exception rather than the rule. That is a weaker outcome than a universal treaty, and a stronger one than another five years of expert meetings.
Washington’s five years is not a delay — it is a different answer
It would be a mistake to read the American working paper as mere stalling. It is a substantive position, and it deserves to be taken seriously on its own terms. Washington argues that existing humanitarian law already governs these weapons, that it has not been established that autonomous weapons are inherently indiscriminate, and that appropriate use of autonomy can reduce the risks to civilians compared with weapons that lack it. There is a real argument there: a machine that identifies a target by its heat signature does not get tired, frightened or angry, and a weapon that can be programmed to abort an attack when a civilian appears in the frame could, in principle, be more discriminate than a human pilot under fire. The problem with the argument is not that it is wrong in principle. It is that it has no answer to the question the Red Cross keeps asking: who is responsible when the machine gets it wrong? A machine cannot be court-martialled. A programmer who wrote code three years ago cannot be said to have pulled a trigger. And a commander who deploys a system he cannot fully predict has, in a meaningful sense, already delegated the decision. The American paper asks for five more years of expert work. The experts have been working for ten. The question is whether five more years of study will produce an answer to the accountability question, or only a more elaborate way of avoiding it.
The battlefield is already answering the question Geneva cannot
While diplomats argue about whether a fully autonomous weapon has ever killed anyone, the technology is moving on without them. AI-assisted weapons are already in use in Ukraine, Gaza and Sudan. Ukrainian civilians report being hunted by drones as they shop or go to school. Both Russian and Ukrainian forces have fielded drones capable of identifying and striking pre-programmed targets even after losing contact with their operators. The New York Times has reported a Russian drone operating entirely through artificial intelligence killing three Ukrainian civilians — a report that has not been independently confirmed, but which nobody in Geneva has been able to refute either. The line between a weapon that a human controls remotely and a weapon that a human merely launches is getting thinner every month, and the distinction the diplomats are arguing about — human in the loop, human on the loop, human out of the loop — is one that the engineers have already blurred. That is why the supporters of controls call this week’s conference the last best chance. It is not that the weapons will be invented in five years. It is that in five years, they will be so widely deployed that regulating them will mean asking armies to give up capabilities they already rely on, rather than asking them to refrain from building capabilities they do not yet have.
Friday will tell us whether the system works at all
The conference is due to decide by Friday, 20 November, whether to open negotiations. There are four plausible outcomes. The first is a binding negotiating mandate, which would be a genuine breakthrough and would vindicate the 13 years of work. The second is a non-binding process, which is what Washington wants and which would keep the talks alive without committing anyone to anything. The third is a compromise — a longer or open-ended negotiating period, with rules that individual states can adopt as binding or non-binding — which would be, in the words of one campaigner, kicking a very dangerous can down the road. The fourth is nothing: another suspension, another procedural objection, another five years until the next review conference. What Friday will really decide is not the future of autonomous weapons. It is whether the Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons is still a functioning instrument for making international law, or whether it has become a place where the states that do not want rules go to make sure no rules are made. If it is the latter, the frustrated majority will have to choose between a treaty without the great powers and no treaty at all. That choice has been made before, with landmines and with cluster munitions. Both times, the treaty without the great powers turned out to matter more than its critics expected. The question in Geneva this week is whether the same will be true of machines that kill.
What to Watch Next
- Whether the informal consultations that began on Tuesday produce an agreed agenda, and whether Russia renews its objection to observers taking part in them.
- What the conference decides by Friday, 20 November: a binding negotiating mandate, a non-binding process, a compromise, or nothing at all.
- Whether the frustrated majority begins, in public, to discuss moving negotiations to the General Assembly or to a stand-alone treaty outside the UN.
- What the United States says in the room about its five-year, non-binding proposal, and whether any other state publicly supports it.
- Whether Britain, France and Germany hold their middle position — a negotiating mandate that leaves the legal form open — or are pushed towards one side.
- Any new evidence, from Ukraine or elsewhere, about fully autonomous weapons being used without human approval, which would change the terms of the debate.
- What Guterres says next: his term as Secretary-General ends this year, and this conference is the last chance for his 2026 deadline to mean anything.
Sources
- NPR — “U.N. talks seek to rein in ‘killer robots’ as fears over AI weapons grow”, by Imogen Foulkes, 16 November 2026
- SOFX — “US, Russia and Israel Oppose Binding Autonomous Weapons Treaty at UN Geneva Talks”, based on Reuters reporting by Olivia Le Poidevin, 17 November 2026
- Geneva Solutions — “Russia’s delay tactics derail UN talks on autonomous weapons in Geneva”, by Kasmira Jefford, 16 November 2026
- United Nations — United States working paper to the Seventh Review Conference of the Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons, CCW/CONF.VII/WP.2, 4 November 2026
- DroneXL — “US Asks UN For Five Years To Write Voluntary Killer Robot Rules”, 16 November 2026
- RoboDaily — “‘A moral red line’? World on cusp of autonomous weapons revolution”, based on AFP reporting, 14 November 2026